Both are good choices. Here’s how to decide which fits your home, your budget, and how long you plan to stay.
Of all the questions we hear during roofing estimates, “Should I go metal or stick with shingles?” comes up the most. Both are solid choices for central Indiana homes. The right one depends on your house, your budget, and your plans.
How long you plan to stay
A metal roof generally lasts considerably longer than an asphalt shingle roof. If this is your forever home, or a farmhouse you plan to pass down, that longer life can make the higher up-front cost worth it. If you expect to sell in a few years, shingles often make more financial sense.
Up-front cost
Shingles usually cost less to install. Metal costs more at the start but typically needs fewer replacements over the life of the home. During a free estimate we’ll price both so you can compare real numbers for your roof, not averages from the internet.
Indiana weather
- Snow and ice: metal sheds snow well, which can help on steeper roofs.
- Wind: properly installed metal panels and quality shingles both hold up well. Installation quality matters as much as the material.
- Hail: heavy hail can dent metal and damage shingles. Ask us about impact-rated options.
Looks and style
Standing-seam metal fits farmhouses, barns, and historic homes beautifully. We recently put a new metal roof on a historic brick home in our area, and it keeps the character of the house. Shingles come in many colors and profiles that suit most traditional homes.
The bottom line
There’s no one right answer. The best roof is the one that fits your home and your plans, installed by a crew that does it right. Call Jesse at (765) 623-0847 and we’ll walk your roof and price both options for free.
